The passing of House Bill 1307 (HB1307) in Hawaii has sparked intense reactions from community members, especially Native Hawaiians, who believe their voices have been overlooked in a critical decision impacting their ancestral lands. This bill focuses on geothermal exploration, a topic that is already controversial, especially given the existing injunction against such practices in Hawaii. Despite significant opposition, the bill moved forward, primarily pushed by those with financial stakes. This situation raises serious questions about legality, ethics, and the preservation of Hawaiian land.
Understanding this issue requires us to look closely at geothermal exploration, the legal frameworks governing Hawaiian lands, and the passionate concerns expressed by Native Hawaiians. This struggle is not just about energy production; it’s about honoring the rights and voices of the Hawaiian people and ensuring their involvement in decisions that influence their lives and cultural heritage.
The Context of HB1307
To grasp the implications of HB1307, it is essential to understand its historical background. The Hawaiian Homes Commission Act of 1921 established lands specifically for Native Hawaiians. Under this law, any decisions regarding these homelands must involve the beneficiaries—the Native Hawaiian community. This act highlights the need for transparency and genuine consultation, both of which appear to be lacking in how HB1307 has progressed.
The Department of the Interior oversees Hawaiian homelands, emphasizing that the engagement of Native Hawaiians is critical. Their voices should shape decisions and protect their rich cultural heritage.
Opponents of HB1307 have raised concerns about numerous procedural bypasses. The testimonies against the bill were mostly from the Native Hawaiian community, contrasting sharply with the few supporting testimonies. For example, the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL) endorsed the bill, despite standing to gain $20 million from geothermal projects. This raises serious ethical questions about who truly benefits from such legislation.
Community Response and Opposition
The significant opposition to HB1307 demonstrates the community's determination to safeguard their rights. Despite receiving very short notice (approximately 24 hours), more than a hundred testimonies against the bill have been submitted, highlighting the community's worries about the environmental and cultural effects of geothermal exploration.
Native Hawaiians worry that geothermal activities will have destructive consequences often overlooked in discussions of energy needs. They liken geothermal extraction to fracking, a process known for severe environmental damage. A report highlighted that injecting millions of gallons of chemicals into active volcanic regions threatens both local ecosystems and the cultural significance of the land.
Organizations like the Royal Order of the Still Standing Hawaiian Kingdom have submitted testimonies opposing the bill. They argue that it undermines cultural rights and violates established laws. This unified response from the community demonstrates a compelling urgency to protect their homeland from decisions made without their input.
The Environmental Impact of Geothermal Energy
One significant aspect of the geothermal energy discussion is its environmental impact. Advocates often label geothermal as a "clean" energy source. However, the reality is a whole lot more complicated.
Geothermal energy extraction often leads to land degradation, habitat loss, and contamination of water resources. Proponents tend to downplay the amount of wastewater generated during this process. Reports indicate up to 6 million gallons of water mixed with chemicals may be injected daily into volcanic formations. This can disrupt local wildlife and pose health risks to surrounding communities.
Moreover, the narrative surrounding "clean" energy demands scrutiny. While geothermal energy is renewable, the extraction methods must prioritize environmental protection. Local concerns about these complexities suggest the need for a more balanced and sustainable approach to energy sourcing that respects nature and community values.
Community Engagement and Awareness
Ongoing discussions around HB1307 highlight the importance of community engagement and education. Understanding the implications of such legislation can empower community members to advocate for their rights and cultural heritage. The substantial evidence from opposition testimonies should serve as a rallying point for all Hawaiians to educate themselves, speak out, and demand accountability from decision-makers.
Communities must actively fight for their inclusion in discussions that threaten their lands and way of life. Power dynamics hinge on who is considered a stakeholder in these decisions. By uniting, Hawaiians can ensure their rightful voices are recognized and respected. When I say Hawaiians I do mean all children of Hawaii , to all subjects of the still standing Hawaiian Kingdom. this IS a Kahea call.
Local perspectives are vital, and the future of Hawaii relies on the community's commitment to inform others and raise awareness about the potential dangers of geothermal exploration.
Navigating the Legal Terrain
The community should also explore legal avenues as they gain insight into their rights established under the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act. Understanding these laws is crucial for advocating for change and making sure that developments comply with legal standards.
A primary concern among opponents is the seemingly illegal push for projects like these without direct consultations with Native Hawaiians. This situation raises critical questions about how laws designed to protect people can be overlooked.
Education builds a foundation for empowerment. By learning these legal frameworks, community members can position themselves to demand respectful engagement in decisions that affect their land.
Moving Forward Together
The passing of HB1307 signifies not just a legislative hurdle; it is a breach of trust and a troubling manipulation of laws meant to safeguard Native Hawaiian rights. In response, it is crucial for the community to unite and resist the disregard for their land and culture.
Geothermal exploration, often falsely promoted as sustainable, must be reassessed in light of the widespread opposition from those it could affect. Through collective education, activism, and persistent efforts for inclusion in decision-making, Native Hawaiians can reclaim their voices.
The future of Hawaii hangs in balance. Engaged community involvement is vital to preserve the sanctity of their land for generations. Now is the time to come together, amplify these voices, and ensure that the true guardians of the land are included in every step of the decision-making process.
By acting decisively today, we can shape a future that honors both the land and the people who have cared for it for centuries. Let us ensure that history does not repeat itself; every voice must be heard, and every concern addressed to protect the rich fabric of Hawaiian culture and life.
Jasmine Steiner
KahuPuna
Aloha Activism
please see this website for more resources and to read and share recent blog articles on the Moku O Keawe community and its 40 year plight against unmonitored and unregulated Geothermal. You can exit this article to the main blog. mahalo.
留言